slideshow widget

Saturday, April 26, 2008

Cardiac asthma should not be treated as asthma

I have spent so much time writing about and educating nurses and students about cardiac asthma that I have decided it needs a post of its own.

And, considering about half of all breathing treatments I do are either for pneumonia or cardiac asthma, I am hereby convinced that even doctors have no clue what the difference between true asthma and cardiac asthma is.

So, that is what we will learn in today's class:

According to the, here is the definition of Cardiac Asthma:
The term "cardiac asthma" refers to wheezing associated with congestive heart failure. It isn't true asthma.
As a result of congestive heart failure, fluid can build up in the lungs (pulmonary dema). This causes signs and symptoms — such as shortness of breath, coughing and wheezing — that may mimic asthma. True asthma is a chronic condition caused by inflammation of the airways, which can lead to breathing difficulties.
The distinction is important because treatments for asthma and heart failure are very different
Cardiac asthma is mainly caused due to increased pressure in the pulmonary vessels causing fluid to fill the air sacs, "preventing them from absorbing oxygen," and making the person feel extremely short-of-breath.
This same increased pulmonary vessel pressure (increased pulmonary vascular resistance) in turn squeezes the bronchioles and causes the wheeze and other symptoms that mimic real asthma, and this is why this "problem" is quite often mistaken for asthma and treated with bronchodilators.

I was flabbergasted when I found this article a few years ago, because I knew I was correct in this, but have not found any evidence to support my claim other than what I learned one day in respiratory therapy school. However, even in RT school, one of my teachers mentioned cardiac asthma and cardiac wheeze, but did not give any further detail.

So, here we have it -- the further detail; the evidence that cardiac asthma and asthma have similar symptoms but must be treated as unique illnesses.

When Cardiac Asthma is treated as bronchospasm, all we are doing is putting in more fluid already fluid filled lungs. What we need to do is give a diuretic to get rid of the fluid and, if the heart is causing the pulmonary edema, perhaps provide drugs to increase the contractility of the heart to reduce the pulmonary pressure.

Other than the heart, there are other diseases that can cause pulmonary edema and, thus, cardiac asthma, and these include pneumonia, exposure to toxin, and high altitudes. It is the job of the nurse, the respiratory therapist and (ahem) the doctor to determine the cause of the symptoms and treat the symptoms appropriately.

We'll consider this RT Cave rule #26: Cardiac Asthma should not be treated as asthma. Throat wheezes, upper airway wheezes, and dyspnea on exertion are signs of cardiac asthma, and a wise medical specialist will not confuse this with asthma.


Steve said...

Thanks for the comments. I like that phrase " The mellow asthmatic" lol. May I use it for a future post?

YEAH, Im pretty much steroid dependent with a maintenance dose of 20mg pred , advair and additional flovent for difficult tapers.

Going from 30 to 20mg is the hardest part of the taper for me.

Ive been on 20 mg daily for the past years, luckily with only minor side effects. When I was younger I was a maintenance dose of 40-60 and sometimes as high as 100 mg per day.I had really severe Cushings syndrome and a ton of other stuff. It took a full year on Methotrexate and high dose inhaled steroids to come off.

So, I take it you're an asthmatic?
Tell me more about the psych thing.
Use my regular email if you want.


Mad Asthmatic said...

I've just been discharged from hospital after a rather traumatic time where I suffered a cardiac and resp arrest due to fluid building up in my lungs and heart and pneumonia. I have been an asthmatic for a long time but have now been told I have got cardiac asthma as well as bronchial asthma. I stumbled across your blog and was really interested in your post. I am walking a bit of a tightrope as withdrawl of my asthma medications causes my lungs to get very wheezy and these wheezes have been shown to be due to the bronchial and not the cardiac asthma. I am now worried about having future attacks because the treatment for each type is so different. Thank you for such an interesting post, it has given me a lot of information.

Mad Asthmatic

priyamno1 said...

This website is informative, visitors will surely be benefited, Its our pleasure to read informative content on this useful website. We have also described about Asthma, Asthma information, Diagnosing Asthma in our website

priyamno1 said...

This website is informative, visitors will surely be benefited, Its our pleasure to read informative content on this useful website. We have also described about Asthma, Allergy and Asthma, Allergic Diseases in our website

oldmanskates said...

This is almost a daily battle on the hospital floor. As an RRT being well informed on this topic brings around better patient care and dissolves friction between the RRT and nursing. The cardiac wheeze is heard loudest with stethoscope on the lower 'neck' and will often transmit fainter wheezes heard throughout the chest. I find most nurses are receptive to the correct treatment when you take the time to share your knowledge. Cheers!

Freadom said...

Thanks oldmanskates. I'm glad you brought this to my attention again. I think I'll make this an RT Cave rule.

modiskar said...

Would there be presence of pedal edema when cardiac asthma surfaces

modiskar said...

Would there be presence of pedal edema when cardiac asthma surfaces

Anonymous said...

I am an ER nurse with severe hard to controll asthma. I have an increasing frustration as noone has any good reasons. I have been told everything from VCD, though multiple normal scopes during attack, anxiety, to I just don't come in soon enough. After multiple intubations, reap arrest leading to collapsed lung, and now pacemaker for pauses, your article intrigues me. When I discussed it with MD, he acted like I was an idiot. Are they resistant to diagnose?

theuniqueldy said...

I just left my new PC and because he said he thinks I have cardiac asthma (and not regular asthma) & do not need the singular I looked up cardiac asthma and found this post. I had CHF several years ago soon after (@ 55) I had my 1st asthma attack (I was hospitalized for 15 days). Thank you so very much for this info